Who will be the next Head Coach of the Cleveland Browns?
By: Casey Stamp and Raymond Lucas Jr.
Reports from the Cleveland Plain Dealer created a buzz in Brownstown, announcing that both General Manager Tom Heckert and Head Coach Pat Shurmur were to be fired on "Black Monday" after the Browns lost the season finale to Pittsburgh. While these reports came as no surprise to fans in Cleveland and indeed around the NFL, they were unconfirmed and widely discussed until the announcement was made Monday morning that both had been let go. Jimmy Haslam and Joe Banner met with the media Monday morning and discussed, among other things, the process going forward for finding the perfect leadership to make the Browns a championship squad a model of consistency like the Steelers and Ravens.
Haslam and Banner announced that the first item on the agenda would be to find a suitable Head Coach for the team and that strong leadership was an essential quality to the position. Several times during the meeting with the press, the question of whether or not top candidates would have the desire to come to Cleveland was posed and Haslam stated time and time again that he believes not only is Cleveland among the best football towns, but that the position itself was extremely desirable and very rewarding.
In his 2 seasons as the Browns Head Coach, Pat Shurmur amassed a 9-23 record. Hardly the type of success that will assure job security, however, members of the coaching staff like Dick Juaron have improved the team in terms of leadership and consistency in some phases of the game. Juaron's 4-3 scheme was so recently adapted that a change might be detrimental to the team in the short term. Haslam announced that he has discussed the changes with the coaching staff and told them that so long as they use the proper methods and keep him informed that they are free to pursue other positions. He also stated that the new Head Coach would be free to either keep the on-hand staff or bring in his own. Either way, the current staff has been warned.
Haslam and Banner made it a priority to stay away from specific names, even though led into questioning that would attempt to pry the information out. They had also said that while the decision was not made until last week that Shurmur and Heckert were to be let go, he had been drawing up a succession plan for such events.
So, who will be the next Head Coach of the cleveland Browns? Let's take an in depth look at some of the likely candidates to lead the young core of players to success.
Chip Kelley (Oregon)
Chip Kelly is currently the head coach of the University of Oregon's football program. Kelly has made the Ducks into a powerhouse in the PAC-10 and is known for his fast-paced spread offenses. He's got plenty of experience in dealing with a young core of players (like the one the Browns have) and has all the makings of a classic "motivator". In his 4 seasons as Oregon's coach, his record is 45-7. Impressive right? Not so fast, the PAC-10 isn't the talent laden powerhouse conference it once was. Teams like USC, UCLA, Oregon State and Stanford don't exactly make for National Championship level competition. While his offensive scheme works well in the NCAA there is doubt that it can translate to pro football. Chip is a top candidate for the job, but he comes with a few question marks despite his impressive accomplishments.
2. Bruce Arians (Indianapolis)
Bruce Arians took over as the interim Head Coach of the Indianapolis Colts while Chuck Pagano was being treated for leukemia. Arians acted as a vocal and spiritual leader for his football team and amassed a 9-3 record, finishing 2nd in the AFC South and just before Pagano's return in week 17, a playoff berth. Before Indianapolis, Arians was the Offensive Coordinator for the Pittsburgh Steelers and helped the team to 2 championships in his tenure. He's also got experience with Cleveland. Arians was the Offensive Coordinator for the Browns from 2001-2003 leading them to a 9-7 record in 2002. His resume speaks for itself and he's a natural born leader. Might be the most attractive candidate on the coaching market. San Diego has also expressed interest in his services so if the Browns want to pursue him, they'll have plenty of tough competition.
3. Andy Reid (Philadelphia)
Change never comes easy, especially when you're talking about the longest tenured coach in the NFL and one of the longest in all of pro sports. Andy Reid coached the Philadelphia Eagles for 14 seasons and attained a 129-88-1 career regular season record and a 10-9 post-season record. Reid never won any championships and in a turbulent city such as Philadelphia, he was able to withstand years of heavy criticism which is definitely something he would need to do in Cleveland. He's already got ties to Joe Banner and there are rumors circulating that he's already been asked to interview for the job. If consistency if the target, Reid might be your guy.
4. Josh McDaniels (New England)
Here's a guy who has already expressed tremendouds interest in the job. He's already stated that if presented with the opportunity to coach the Browns, he would accept. He is currently the Offensive Coordinator and the QB coach of the most consistent team in the NFL over the last decade, the New England Patriots. McDaniels has worked under Bill Belichick for many years and has held many different titles within the Patriots organization. He was also the Head Coach of the Denver Broncos from 2009-2010 where his record was 11-17. While McDaniels seems a likely candidate for the position, his experience isn't exactly as enticing as some of the others on this list. He might be a backup plan to some of the bigger names. A sure thing to fall back on. Nonetheless, he does have experience managing high-end QB's such as Tom Brady and Jay Cutler.
5. Bill O'Brien (Penn State)
Bill O'Brien had arguably the toughest join in all of football in 2012. Picking up the shattered remains of the legacy of a tarnished Penn State hero: Joe Paterno. Many of Penn State's players transferred to other programs to avoid the sanctions that would be placed on the school in the wake of the Jerry Sandusky scandal but O'Brien rallied the team to an 8-4 record, a much more successful season than anyone had anticipated. O'Brien was named Big 10 Coach Of The Year on November 27th and received ESPN's National Coach Of The Year award. While these accomplishments alone are impressive, O'Brien also worked with the New England Patriots for a number of years from 2007-2010 holding many different titles. You want a hard-nosed gritty, motivational NFL style coach? This might just be your guy. He's perfect for a town like Cleveland whose image in the NFL is in desperate need of redemption.
So who will it be? It could be one of these five or numerous others such as Lovie Smith (released by the Bears) or David Shaw (Stanford) or Nick Saban but one thing is for sure, it takes a special type of personality to thrive in Cleveland where the media is known for being ruthless at times and where grace periods dont exist. My personal favorite is Bruce Arians. It's a long shot, but Arians exhibited exactly the type of leadership Haslam and Banner were looking for this year with the Indianapolis Colts. If indeed ownership is interested in Arians, they'll need to present an enticing enough offer to draw him off the market.